Skip to content
Mpumalanga Press

Mpumalanga Press

FOR THE PEOPLE BY THE PEOPLE

  • Stage 2 load shedding implemented
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-16
  • Mabuyane reshuffles EC executive council
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-16
  • Former Rustenburg municipal manager charged for R11m security contract
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-16
  • Toyota plant reopens following eThekwini floods
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-16
  • Govt seeks expert panel on captive lion industry exit strategy
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-16
  • Government reflects on tragic Marikana incident
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-16
  • Public Works Minister conducts oversight monitoring visit in KZN
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-16
  • President Ramaphosa heads to SADC Summit
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-16
  • Long waiting list to receive organs in SA
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-16
  • De Lille speaks out against gender-based violence
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-16
  • Condolences for renowned musician Tokollo Tshabalala
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-15
  • Communication research key to SA’s pandemic management
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-15
  • Promoting healing and providing socio-economic redress
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-15
  • Nedbank slapped with R35m administrative sanction
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-15
  • Department cracks down on child labour in Marabastad
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-15
  • Stage 2 load shedding implemented
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-16
  • Mabuyane reshuffles EC executive council
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-16
  • Former Rustenburg municipal manager charged for R11m security contract
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-16
  • Toyota plant reopens following eThekwini floods
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-16
  • Govt seeks expert panel on captive lion industry exit strategy
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-16
  • Government reflects on tragic Marikana incident
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-16
  • Public Works Minister conducts oversight monitoring visit in KZN
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-16
  • President Ramaphosa heads to SADC Summit
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-16
  • Long waiting list to receive organs in SA
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-16
  • De Lille speaks out against gender-based violence
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-16
  • Condolences for renowned musician Tokollo Tshabalala
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-15
  • Communication research key to SA’s pandemic management
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-15
  • Promoting healing and providing socio-economic redress
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-15
  • Nedbank slapped with R35m administrative sanction
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-15
  • Department cracks down on child labour in Marabastad
    Source: SAnews - South African News Published on 2022-08-15

  • Latest news
  • All News
    • National News
    • Local News
    • Business and Finance News
    • Crime News
    • Other News
  • Lifestyle
    • HealthHealth News
    • EntertainmentEntertainment News
  • Sport
  • About us
    • Staff Directory
  • Downloads
  • Contact
    • Your story
  • Terms & conditions
  • Local

No constitutional right to stupidity, says judge

Cape High Court upholds judgment of almost R7-million award against Road Accident Fund.
3 min read

No constitutional right to stupidity, says judge

By Tania Broughton

The Western Cape High Court has dismissed an application by the Road Accident Fund. Archive photo: Ashraf Hendricks

  • The Western Cape High Court has upheld a judgment of almost R7-million awarded to a road accident victim in 2020.

  • Judge Daniel Thulare said that the Road Accident Fund had elected not to participate in judicial proceedings when the matter was first before the court.

  • The Fund “cannot be allowed to play hide when they are served with court processes” Thulare said.

The Road Accident Fund (RAF) got a tongue-lashing from the Western Cape High Court on Thursday for attempting to rescind and set aside almost R7-million awarded to a road accident victim.

Judge Daniel Thulare had to consider whether a judgment granted in favour of the victim on 7 December 2020, where the RAF elected not to participate in judicial proceedings, should be rescinded.

The RAF, in its application, argued that if the order made in favour of victim Johanna Elizabeth McDonnell, was not rescinded, it would result in a serious injustice. The RAF’s case was that it was applying for the rescission primarily because its Chief Operating Officer was not prepared to sign off on the payment.

Read the judgment

According to court papers, the Fund argued that it previously used a panel of attorneys to assist with litigation in unsettled claims. But to cut costs, it had done away with this. The “short-term consequence” was that the Fund had no representation in disputed court matters.

It claimed that McDonnell had only suffered a minor whiplash-type injury and had gone back to work shortly after the accident.

But McDonnell claimed that her injuries were far more serious as she had undergone surgery. She had also presented with a life-long pain disorder. She said that her injury had significantly and permanently compromised the quality of her life.

The matter was set down for trial on 7 December 2020. McDonnell, her employer at the time of the accident, a physiotherapist and psychologist had testified. Expert reports of others were handed in. The RAF was not present, even though the judge stood the matter down to arrange for a representative to be contacted to attend. Judgment in favour of McDonnell was made in default.

On Thursday, Judge Thulare said the RAF’s inability to appoint a firm of attorneys to handle the matter was “unexplained”.

“The RAF pleads for a revolving door … where it simply disregards its obligations to attend court to have issues determined after hearing evidence,” he said. The fact that the RAF had not been represented at the hearing was a “deliberate mistake grounded in some stubborn, militant and ill-advised misdirection.”

“Courts cannot tolerate even the slightest impression that there is a constitutional guaranteed right to plain stupidity. The message should be clear and unequivocal, no-one disregards our laws and then creatively seeks to rewrite the legal prescripts to have a time of carefree fun in litigation, especially with the lives of the injured and vulnerable,” he said.

Thulare said there were two essential elements of “sufficient cause” when considering rescission applications on default judgments. (1) The party must present a reasonable and acceptable explanation for being in default. (2) On the merits, the party has a bona fide defence with some prospect of success.

He said it seemed the RAF’s executives believed their views and processes to be above the law. “RAF cannot be allowed to play hide when they are served with court processes and expect the claimant to join in the game and play seek when the order is against the RAF.

“In essence the RAF requires that its defence before (the trial judge) be restored to life in circumstances where it chose its own process at the expense of judicial processes,” he said. He dismissed the application, and ordered the RAF to pay the costs on attorney and client scale, such costs to include fees of two counsel.

Published originally on GroundUp .

© 2022 GroundUp. This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

About Post Author

Ulandi Bekker

See author's posts

Continue Reading

Previous: Mpumalanga COGTA HOD arrested
Next: Courier vehicle robbers arrested in Mpumalanga

Related Stories

Victim unharmed after being rescued from alleged kidnapping for ransom, one suspect arrested Victim unharmed after being rescued from alleged kidnapping for ransom, one suspect arrested
2 min read
  • Crime
  • Local

Victim unharmed after being rescued from alleged kidnapping for ransom, one suspect arrested

Aug 17, 2022
Potential witness arrested for contempt of court Potential witness arrested for contempt of court
2 min read
  • Crime
  • Local

Potential witness arrested for contempt of court

Aug 15, 2022
Rigid murderer to serve 18 years for murder Rigid murderer to serve 18 years for murder
2 min read
  • Crime
  • Local

Rigid murderer to serve 18 years for murder

Aug 15, 2022

You may have missed

Victim unharmed after being rescued from alleged kidnapping for ransom, one suspect arrested Victim unharmed after being rescued from alleged kidnapping for ransom, one suspect arrested
2 min read
  • Crime
  • Local

Victim unharmed after being rescued from alleged kidnapping for ransom, one suspect arrested

Aug 17, 2022
The key to treating TB may be in a common carbohydrate. What we know so far The key to treating TB may be in a common carbohydrate. What we know so far
4 min read
  • Health

The key to treating TB may be in a common carbohydrate. What we know so far

Aug 17, 2022
African digital innovators are turning plastic waste into value – but there are gaps African digital innovators are turning plastic waste into value – but there are gaps
4 min read
  • Lifestyle

African digital innovators are turning plastic waste into value – but there are gaps

Aug 16, 2022
SME employees not saving enough for retirement SME employees not saving enough for retirement
3 min read
  • Business
  • Finance

SME employees not saving enough for retirement

Aug 16, 2022
Copyright © Mpumalanga Press. All rights reserved. https://upgrader.co.za | DarkNews by AF themes.